Two adjustable caps, one real difference
Both women's Fightin Phils caps in this comparison use an adjustable closure, so neither locks you into a single size. That makes the choice less about measurement and more about which New Era silhouette, colorway and logo you want on your head.
The catalog gives you two clear paths: the New Era 9Twenty Women's Navy Reading Fightin Phils Script Adjustable Hat at USD 20.43 (compared with USD 27.99), and the New Era 9Forty Women's Pink F-Fist Clutch Adjustable Hat at USD 16.24 (compared with USD 24.99). Both are listed as women's-specific styles with adjustable strapback closures.
What each listing confirms about fit
- New Era 9Twenty Women's Navy Reading Fightin Phils Script Adjustable Hat: New Era 9Twenty style with an adjustable strapback closure The 9Twenty name and strapback are the core fit facts here; the strap is what lets you tighten or loosen the cap.

New Era 9Twenty Women's Navy Reading Fightin Phils Script Adjustable Hat - New Era 9Twenty Women's Navy Reading Fightin Phils Script Adjustable Hat: Designed specifically for women This tells you the cut is intended for women's sizing rather than a unisex shape.
- New Era 9Forty Women's Pink F-Fist Clutch Adjustable Hat: Adjustable 9Forty silhouette ensures a comfortable, customizable fit The 9Forty is the other New Era shape in this pair, and the listing frames adjustability as its fit promise.

New Era 9Forty Women's Pink F-Fist Clutch Adjustable Hat - New Era 9Forty Women's Pink F-Fist Clutch Adjustable Hat: Designed in a women's-specific style Like the 9Twenty, this cap is cut for women, so the decision is about silhouette and style, not gender sizing.
How to read the 9Twenty vs 9Forty names
New Era uses these numbers as model names, and the supplied records describe each cap as adjustable. What the records do not include is a crown height, a head circumference range or a structured-versus-unstructured description. That means you should not treat the model number as a guaranteed fit profile from this listing alone.
If you already know how a New Era 9Twenty or 9Forty feels on you, use that memory as your guide. If you don't, the adjustable strapback is your safety net: you can fine-tune the fit after the cap arrives rather than committing to a fixed size.
Navy script vs pink F-Fist: choosing by look
- New Era 9Twenty Women's Navy Script Hat: Navy crown and front panel with the Fightin Phils script logo. A classic, understated colorway that pairs easily with everyday outfits and game-day layers.
- New Era 9Forty Women's Pink F-Fist Clutch Hat: Pink crown and visor with a contrasting F-Fist logo on the front. A bolder, more playful look for fans who want the cap to be the statement.
- Price difference: The 9Forty pink cap is listed at USD 16.24 versus USD 20.43 for the navy 9Twenty. Both show a higher comparison price, so check the current listing before you decide on price alone.
A simple way to pick your Fightin Phils cap
- Start with the color you will actually wear: Navy is the safer everyday choice; pink is the fun, standout option. Neither is wrong, but one will get more wear from your closet.
- Then consider the logo style: The script logo reads traditional, while the F-Fist logo is bolder. Match it to the rest of your Fightin Phils gear.
- Use the adjustable strapback as your fit check: Both caps tighten and loosen, so pick the style you prefer and adjust the fit when it arrives.
- Check the listing before checkout: Confirm the current price and that the women's-specific style is the one you want.
What the listings leave open
The supplied records do not confirm care instructions, exact head-size ranges or crown measurements for either cap. If those details matter to you, check the product page or contact the store before ordering rather than assuming a fit based on the model number.
Both caps are official New Era products in the Reading Fightin Phils collection, so the real decision comes down to colorway, logo and which adjustable silhouette you prefer wearing.



